Humans have chased sweetness since the days of wild honey and ripe fruit. Cane sugar was crystallised and produced at scale in India centuries ago; global output then surged with colonial plantations and later industrial mills. Our intake rose from rare luxury to a daily staple, far beyond what our biology adapted to handle. Artificial sweeteners emerged as the lab-made fix for our sugar indulgence. Saccharin arrived in 1879 by accident, then cyclamate, aspartame, sucralose, acesulfame K, plus plant-derived options like stevia and monk fruit extract. Their appeal is obvious: intense sweetness with almost no calories.

Related story: Sugar is Addictive: Here’s How it Rewires Your Brain

Sweetness and calories

Sugar is a carbohydrate with about 4 calories per gram. A teaspoon pumps energy and glycemic impact. Many artificial sweeteners are about 100-600 times sweeter than table sugar by weight (aspartame \~200×, sucralose \~600×), so you use micro amounts and get essentially zero calories. If you replace sugar with these, you cut immediate energy intake. That trade-off underpins products like diet soda and sugar-free yoghurt: they keep the sweetness while cutting most of the sugar and calories.

Related story: Healthy Sugar Alternatives

Metabolism and blood sugar

Sugar breaks down into glucose and fructose. Glucose spikes blood sugar and insulin. Fructose gets shuttled to the liver, and in excess, can turn into fat. Extra glucose does the same once glycogen stores are full. That sugar rush and crash? Classic insulin response and rapid swings in blood glucose.

Artificial sweeteners mostly slip through as passengers, not fuel. They don’t raise blood glucose the way sugar does. There's nuance, though. Sweetness without calories still stirs up surprising reactions in the body, proof that “zero calories” doesn’t mean zero effect.

Related story: 7 Surprising Things That Can Spike Your Blood Sugar

Long-term health picture

High added sugar intake is convincingly tied to weight gain, insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes, high triglycerides, fatty liver, hypertension, and higher cardiovascular risk. Hence, the global push to keep free sugars below roughly 10% of daily calories, ideally closer to 5.

Artificial sweeteners are approved and considered safe at typical intakes (aspartame 40–50 mg/kg/day, sucralose 5 mg/kg/day, acesulfame K 15 mg/kg/day, stevia 4 mg/kg/day) by major regulators. While fears about them directly causing cancer haven't held up at normal consumption levels, that doesn’t make them a free pass for health; using them as a long-term strategy is still questionable. Beyond that, they’re not always problem-free: some people experience digestive upset from sugar alcohols, often bundled into sugar-free products; people with PKU (a rare disorder where the body can’t process phenylalanine) must avoid aspartame, since it contains phenylalanine that can build up to harmful levels.

Related story: 7 Ways to Control High Blood Sugar in the Morning

Practical Guardrails

• Audit your liquid sugar. Regular soda, sweet tea, energy drinks, and fancy coffees are the stealth heavy hitters. Swap to water, seltzer, or diet as a transition, then aim for unsweetened most days.
   
• Save added sweetness for foods you truly value. Bake, savour, and keep portions honest.
   
• Eat fibre with sweets. Whole fruit beats juice. Yoghurt with berries beats sweetened yoghurt.
   
• Watch for compensation. If diet soda nudges you toward larger portions later, adjust the plan.
   
• Keep kids on lower sweetness overall. Early habits set the taste baseline.

Related story: 5 Ways Sugars Are Hiding in Plain Sight in Your Food

Let's have a look at some of the main differences:

Related story: How to Balance Your Blood Sugar

The verdict

When it comes to sugar versus artificial sweeteners, neither side wears a perfect halo. Sugar is natural but calorie-dense, quick to spike blood glucose, and a driver of long-term health risks when consumed in excess. Artificial sweeteners, on the other hand, offer sweetness without calories and are considered safe within recommended limits, but they don’t erase cravings or guarantee better health outcomes.

The real takeaway isn’t about picking one over the other; it's about rethinking our relationship with sweetness itself. Diet soda may be a step up from regular soda, and swapping sugar for stevia in your coffee can cut calories, but the bigger win lies in training your palate toward less sweetness overall. Whole foods, fruit, and occasional treats can satisfy without tipping into overload.

Get instant access to personalised nutrition advice just for you. Sign up here.