Every December, gratitude shows up with instructions. Some make a gratitude list, others count their blessings, and still others focus on the good. And while all of that sounds harmless, it can quietly become exhausting, especially if this year stretched you emotionally, physically, or mentally. When life has been uneven, gratitude can start to feel like homework you don’t have the energy to complete.

So here’s a different way to think about it this Christmas: What if gratitude wasn’t about feeling joyful at all? What if it were simply about noticing what helped you keep going?

Related story: 6 Gratitude Practices For Your Well-Being

Gratitude Isn’t Happiness, It’s About Awareness

We often confuse gratitude with joy, but psychology treats them differently. Joy is a feeling, while gratitude is a form of awareness. Neuroscience research indicates that gratitude activates brain areas associated with social connection and meaning, rather than the pleasure systems linked to happiness. A 2020 study published in Scientific Reports found that gratitude involves recognising intention, care, or support, even in difficult situations.

That means you don’t need to feel cheerful to be grateful. You only need to notice what matters. This distinction matters greatly during the holidays, when people often carry grief, fatigue, loneliness, or burnout alongside the festivities.

Related story: 5 Easy Mindfulness Habits To Improve Your Mental Health

Why Forced Gratitude Often Feels Wrong

If you’ve ever tried to write a gratitude list and felt irritated, guilty, or oddly empty, it’s not inexplicable. Research suggests that gratitude practices lose their effectiveness when they feel compulsory or emotionally mismatched. A review in The Journal of Positive Psychology (2017) found that gratitude interventions are most effective when they allow space for negative emotions, rather than attempting to bypass them.

In other words, gratitude is most effective when it is grounded in reality. This is why the simple question, “What are you thankful for?” can feel strangely heavy. It assumes the answer should be positive, neat, and emotionally uplifting.

Related story: 3 Mindfulness Exercises to Improve Focus

Gratitude as Noticing, Not Performing

Instead of trying to generate a feeling, you simply observe. Psychologists describe this as reflective noticing, paying attention to moments of meaning, support, or stability without evaluating whether they made you happy. Research published in Emotion (2015) demonstrates that this type of reflection enhances emotional regulation and psychological flexibility.

Noticing doesn’t demand optimism. It allows mixed emotions. You can acknowledge both exhaustion and appreciation simultaneously. That’s what makes it sustainable.

Better Questions for a Difficult Year

If the usual gratitude prompts feel off, try these instead. They work because they don’t ask you to feel a certain way.

• “What got you through this year?” This recognises effort and endurance, not just outcomes.
• “What helped on the days that felt heavy?” Support doesn’t have to be dramatic to matter.
• "Who showed up consistently, even in small ways?”
• “What did you learn about yourself this year?” Growth often comes from strain, not celebration.
• “What stayed steady when other things felt uncertain?” Sometimes gratitude is about reliability, not excitement.

These questions tend to feel gentler because they don’t rush you toward positivity. They let meaning emerge naturally.

Related story: Self-Care Habits of Mental Health Experts

What Gratitude Actually Does Over Time

When practised without pressure, gratitude has measurable effects on mental health. Studies in Frontiers in Psychology (2019) show that reflective gratitude can reduce stress responses and improve emotional balance over time.

Importantly, these benefits don’t require daily journaling or long rituals; even occasional reflection, once or twice a week, can be effective.

Related story: 9 Steps to Instant Self-Care

How to Practice Soft Gratitude This Christmas

You don’t need to overhaul your routine. Try one simple approach:

• One honest sentence a day: “Today, what helped was…”
• Speaking instead of writing: A short voice note can feel more natural than a journal.
• Conversation-based reflection: Ask someone you trust one gentle question and listen without fixing or reframing.
• Non-daily practice: Let it happen when it feels accessible. Skipping days doesn’t undo the benefit.

Related story: Self-Care Checklist For Every Day of The Month

This version of gratitude allows Christmas to be what it actually is, not what it’s supposed to be. You can feel relief without excitement, appreciation without happiness, and gratitude without celebration.

Mindfulness 101:Bring calm into your day with these daily tips. Sign up here.